Reduced circulating dendritic cells in acute Plasmodium knowlesi and Plasmodium falciparum malaria despite elevated plasma Flt3 ligand levels

Abstract

Background

Plasmodium falciparum malaria increases plasma levels of the cytokine Fms-like tyrosine kinase 3 ligand (Flt3L), a haematopoietic factor associated with dendritic cell (DC) expansion. It is unknown if the zoonotic parasite Plasmodium knowlesi impacts Flt3L or DC in human malaria. This study investigated circulating DC and Flt3L associations in adult malaria and in submicroscopic experimental infection.

Methods

Plasma Flt3L concentration and blood CD141⁺ DC, CD1c⁺ DC and plasmacytoid DC (pDC) numbers were assessed in (i) volunteers experimentally infected with P. falciparum and in Malaysian patients with uncomplicated (ii) P. falciparum or (iii) P. knowlesi malaria.

Results

Plasmodium knowlesi caused a decline in all circulating DC subsets in adults with malaria. Plasma Flt3L was elevated in acute P. falciparum and P. knowlesi malaria with no increase in a subclinical experimental infection. Circulating CD141⁺ DCs, CD1c⁺ DCs and pDCs declined in all adults tested, for the first time extending the finding of DC subset decline in acute malaria to the zoonotic parasite P. knowlesi.

Conclusions

In adults, submicroscopic Plasmodium infection causes no change in plasma Flt3L but does reduce circulating DCs. Plasma Flt3L concentrations increase in acute malaria, yet this increase is insufficient to restore or expand circulating CD141⁺ DCs, CD1c⁺ DCs or pDCs. These data imply that haematopoietic factors, yet to be identified and not Flt3L, involved in the sensing/maintenance of circulating DC are impacted by malaria and a submicroscopic infection. The zoonotic P. knowlesi is similar to other Plasmodium spp in compromising DC in adult malaria.

Background

Human blood dendritic cells (DCs) are a heterogeneous population of antigen presenting cells, comprising several subsets with distinct phenotypes and functions [1]. Peripheral blood DCs can be divided into myeloid DCs (mDCs or classical DCs) and plasmacytoid DCs (pDCs), and are identified by their surface expression of CD11c and CD123, respectively [2]. There are three phenotypically distinct subpopulations of mDCs based on expression of CD1c (BDCA1⁺, DC2), CD16⁺ (FcγRIII) and CD141⁺ (BDCA3⁺, DC1) [1, 3]. DCs are key activators of the adaptive immune response to pathogens [4], including the malaria causing parasite Plasmodium [5]. Previous studies have shown that during experimental blood-stage Plasmodium infection [6,7,8,9,10], and in adults with uncomplicated Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax malaria [11,12,13] numbers of all DC subsets are reduced in the periphery. The effect of the zoonotic parasite Plasmodium knowlesi on circulating DC subsets in human malaria is yet to be determined.

DC homeostasis is in part regulated by the haematopoietic cytokine FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 ligand (Flt3L) [14,15,16]. A role for Flt3L in DC development was uncovered when mice and humans were administered Flt3L and DC numbers subsequently expanded [14, 17]. Further, bone marrow progenitors treated with FLT3L, preferentially support the development of mature DCs in vitro [18]. In murine malaria, Flt3L preferentially stimulates the expansion of CD8α⁺ CD103⁺ DCs which activate CD8⁺ T cells [19]. In humanized mice, Flt3L is associated with CD141⁺ DC expansion, and the maintenance and expansion of other DC subsets including CD1c⁺ DCs and pDC [15].

In children with severe P. falciparum malaria, Plasmodium-induced Flt3L is reported to selectively stimulate the expansion of blood CD141⁺ DCs, but not other DC subsets [19]. Increased Flt3L is observed in adults with uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria [20], yet associations with DCs have not been investigated in adults. Here, plasma Flt3L and circulating DC numbers were quantified in adults experimentally infected with P. falciparum, and adults with clinical P. falciparum or P. knowlesi malaria to better understand the impact of a Plasmodium infection on circulating DC numbers and their association with plasma Flt3L levels.

Methods

Ethics statement

Written and informed consent was obtained from all participants. The clinical malaria study in Malaysia was approved by the ethics committees of Menzies School of Health Research (HREC 10/1431) and the Malaysian Ministry of Health (NMRR 10-754-6684). Volunteer infection studies were approved by the Human Research Ethics Committees of QIMR Berghofer Medical Research Institute (P1479) and Menzies School of Health Research (HREC 10/1431).

Cohorts

Clinical malaria

DC number were assessed in cryopreserved PBMCs and Flt3L in plasma collected from patients with uncomplicated P. falciparum (n = 11) or P. knowlesi malaria (n = 14) participating in a pathophysiology study at Queen Elizabeth and Kudat District Hospitals in Sabah, Malaysia [21, 22]. Post treatment PBMC and plasma were collected 28 days after anti-malarial treatment (Table 1). PBMC and plasma samples from PCR Plasmodium-negative adult visitors on the infectious disease ward were evaluated as controls (n = 15).

Table 1 Acute malaria patients and induced blood-stage malaria (IBSM) cohort information

Induced blood-stage malaria (IBSM) studies

For participants in experimental infection studies (n = 33), inoculum preparation, recruitment, infection and monitoring was performed as described previously [6, 23]. For assessment of CD141⁺ DCs, anticoagulated blood was collected prior to infection, 24 h prior to treatment, at the time of treatment and 24 h post treatment. Anti-malarial drugs were administered when volunteers reached a pre-determined parasitaemia threshold, median parasitaemia 5284 [IQR 1349–11,058] parasites/mL (day 7 or 8). Plasma samples were collected from volunteers before infection and at peak infection, plasma was cryopreserved within 30 min of blood collection. For CD141⁺ DCs characterization and function fresh whole blood was processed within 2 h of collection. Volunteers were recruited from clinical trials registered with US NIH ClinicalTrails.gov (ACTRN12611001203943, registered November 23, 2011; ACTRN12612000323820, registered March 21, 2012; ACTRN12612000814875, registered August 3, 2012; ACTRN12613000565741, registered May 17, 2013; ACTRN12613001040752, registered September 18, 2013; NCT02281344, registered October 3, 2014).

Flt3L detection by ELISA

Plasma Flt3L levels were detected using human Flt-3 Ligand Quantikine ELISA kit (DFK00, R&D Systems), as per manufacturer’s instructions. Heparin plasma samples for each individual participant were tested in duplicate. Absorbance was measured at 450 nm and plasma Flt3L concentration was calculated using standards provided in the kit (minimum sensitivity less than 7 pg/mL). Mean concentration of duplicates tested is reported.

DC subset enumeration

200 µL of fresh whole blood or 3 million PBMCs were stained at RT with surface antibodies, CD3 (HIT3a), CD14 (HCD14), CD19 (HIB19), CD56 (HCD56), HLA-DR (L243), CD11c (B-Ly6), CD123 (6H6), CD303 (201A), CD1c (L161), CD141 (M80), all antibodies were purchased from BD biosciences or Biolegend. For whole blood, RBCs were lysed with FACS lysing solution (BD) and cells fixed with 1% (w/v) paraformaldehyde in phosphate-buffered saline. Absolute numbers of DCs were determined by adding automated lymphocyte and monocyte counts (10⁹ cells/L), dividing the sum by 100, multiplying the percentage of DCs, and multiplying the product by 1000 to give the cell count/µL.

FACS data was acquired using a FACSCanto™ II (BD, USA) or Gallios™ (Beckman Coulter, USA) and data analysed using Kaluza^® 1.3 (Beckman Coulter, USA) and Flowjo V10.6 (BD, USA).

Statistics

Statistical analyses used GraphPad Prism 6 (Graphpad Software Inc., USA). To compare within patient changes, the Wilcoxon matched-pairs sign rank test was used and the Mann–Whitney test was used to compare between patient changes (healthy controls versus malaria patients). Tests were two-tailed and considered significant with p-values < 0.05.

Results

CD141⁺ numbers significantly decline during primary subpatent P. falciparum infection without detectable changes in plasma FLT3L

CD1c⁺ DC and pDC numbers decline during experimental P. falciparum infection [6, 7]. Here, CD141⁺ DCs were measured in fresh whole blood collected from volunteers participating in experimental infection studies (Fig. 1a). Following primary experimental P. falciparum blood-stage infection, CD141⁺ DC numbers significantly decreased by day 6/7 (24 h before reaching the predefined threshold “peak” for treatment), and remained decreased for at least 24 h post treatment (Fig. 1b).

Fig. 1

CD141⁺ DCs decline in malaria-naive volunteers experimentally infected with P. falciparum. a CD141⁺ DC gating. CD141⁺ DCs were identified as negative for lineage markers, HLA-DR⁺, CD11c⁺ and CD141⁺. b The absolute number of circulating CD141⁺ DCs in malaria naive volunteers experimentally infected with P. falciparum (d0; n = 33, − 24 h to peak; n = 26, peak; n = 33, + 24 h to peak n = 26). c Plasma Flt3L levels in malaria-naive volunteers experimentally infected with P. falciparum before infection (day 0) and at day predefined threshold for treatment reached (peak), n = 7. d Correlation of CD141⁺ DC number and Flt3L concentration on day 0 (left plot), correlation of CD141⁺ DC number and Flt3L concentration at peak infection (middle plot) and correlation of CD141⁺ DC number at peak infection and Flt3L concentration at day 0 (right plot) in volunteer infection studies. Box plots show the 10–90th percentile, median and interquartile range for data from all participants. The Wilcoxon matched-paired sign rank test was used to compare matched data. Spearman correlation was used for linear regression tests. Tests were two-tailed and considered significant if p-values < 0.05

Plasma Flt3L was measured before infection (day 0) and at peak-infection. There was no change in plasma Flt3L levels (Fig. 1c). There was no correlation between plasma Flt3L and CD141⁺ DCs before infection, at treatment nor between pre-infection and the treatment time point (Fig. 1d). Similarly, there was no correlation between plasma Flt3L and other pDC or CD1c⁺ DC subsets analysed previously [6, 7] (Additional file 1: Fig. S1A, 1B).

DC subsets decline in adults with acute uncomplicated P. falciparum or P. knowlesi malaria

DC subset numbers in cryopreserved PBMCs were measured from patients with acute falciparum or knowlesi malaria as well as in-country uninfected healthy controls (Fig. 2a). During clinical malaria, plasmacytoid DCs (pDCs), CD1c⁺ DCs (BDCA1, DC2) and CD141⁺ DCs (BDCA3, DC1) numbers significantly decreased in both P. falciparum and P. knowlesi infection when compared to healthy uninfected controls (Fig. 2b–d). At convalescence (28 days post treatment), patient DC subset numbers recovered to comparable levels to healthy uninfected controls (Fig. 2b–d).

Fig. 2

DC subsets decline in adults with acute clinical malaria. a DC subsets were identified as negative for lineage markers and HLA-DR⁺. Specifically, pDC were identified by CD303⁺ expression; CD1c⁺ DC were identified by CD1c⁺ (BDCA1) expression and CD141⁺ by CD141⁺ (BDCA3) expression. The absolute number of circulating b pDC (red), c CD1c⁺ DC (green) and d CD141⁺ DC (blue) in clinical malaria patients with P. falciparum (acute n = 7, conval = 6, circles) or P. knowlesi (acute n = 12, conval = 8, triangles) compared to local healthy controls (n = 5, healthy, squares). Box plots show the 10–90th percentile, median and interquartile range for data from all participants. The Mann–Whitney T-test was used to compare unpaired data (healthy vs acute and healthy vs conval). Tests were two-tailed and considered significant if p-values < 0.05

Plasma Flt3L increased in adults with uncomplicated falciparum or knowlesi malaria

Plasma Flt3L was measured in adult patients with acute falciparum or knowlesi malaria and healthy uninfected controls. Plasma Flt3L was significantly increased in adults with falciparum (p = 0.0003) or knowlesi (p < 0.0001) malaria, compared to healthy uninfected local controls (Fig. 3a). At convalescence (28 days post treatment), patient Flt3L levels were comparable to healthy uninfected controls (Fig. 3a). There was no significant correlation between plasma Flt3L and parasitaemia in patients with falciparum or knowlesi malaria (Additional file 1: Fig. S2). There was no significant correlation between plasma Flt3L levels during acute infection and DC subset numbers at convalescence (Fig. 3b, c).

Fig. 3

Increased plasma Flt3L in adults with acute P. falciparum or P. knowlesi malaria. a Plasma Flt3L levels in clinical malaria patients with either P. falciparum, (n = 10, circles) or P. knowlesi (n = 13, triangles) malaria (acute) compared to convalescence (conval) or compared to local uninfected healthy controls (n = 12, healthy, squares). Correlation of DC subset number at convalescence (conval) and Flt3L concentration at acute infection for pDC (left plots), CD1c⁺ DC (middle plots) and CD141⁺ DC (right plots) in b P. falciparum and c P. knowlesi clinical malaria. Box plots show the 10–90th percentile, median and interquartile range for data from all participants. The Wilcoxon matched-pairs sign rank test was used to compare matched data and Mann–Whitney T-test was used to compare unpaired data (healthy vs acute) and Spearman’s rank correlation was used for correlations. Tests were two-tailed and considered significant if p-values < 0.05

Discussion

The relationship between DCs and Flt3L during malaria is incompletely understood. Here we show that similar to CD1c⁺ DCs and pDC subsets, circulating CD141⁺ DCs decline in numbers during experimental P. falciparum infection. Despite this decline, there was no detectable perturbation of plasma Flt3L in a first sub-microscopic infection in adults. Furthermore, the previously reported loss of pDC, CD1c⁺ DC and CD141⁺ DC subsets was confirmed in adults with acute falciparum malaria; and for the first time a significant decline in pDC, CD1c⁺ DC and CD141⁺ DC subsets in acute uncomplicated knowlesi malaria is reported. Previous reports show that plasma Flt3L is elevated in falciparum malaria, and here, for the first time elevated plasma Flt3L in patients with knowlesi malaria is reported, suggesting a pan Plasmodium effect of increased Flt3L in malaria. However, there was no association between plasma Flt3L and CD141⁺ DCs, in either adults with uncomplicated malaria or submicroscopic infection. These data may imply that other haematopoetic factors such as GM-CSF, M-CSF and/or IL-4 may be involved individually or in combination with Flt3L for the maintenance of circulating DC [24] and highlight the complicated relationship between DC subsets and Flt3L during malaria.

Early dysfunction of DCs during experimental malaria has been reported previously [6, 10]. Here, CD141⁺ DCs are also lost from peripheral circulation during experimental P. falciparum infection. Loss of CD141⁺ DCs during experimental P. vivax infection in healthy adult volunteers [25], in clinical P. vivax [12, 13] and now also clinical knowlesi malaria suggests a clear pan Plasmodium effect on CD141⁺ DCs in adults with subpatent or clinical malaria. Indeed, all DC subsets are reduced in both falciparum and knowlesi malaria. Changes in peripheral DC numbers during malaria may be explained by DC migration [26], DC apoptosis [13] or the failure to re-populate DCs from the bone marrow [27]. Increased expression of apoptotic markers annexin V [10] and caspase-3 [6] on DC subsets has been shown, suggesting, early apoptosis may contribute to premature loss of DCs. Future studies are required to establish whether the marked loss of CD141⁺ DCs from the circulation during Plasmodium infection is due to migration to organs such as the spleen and to identify haematopoietic factors that may be impaired by Plasmodium infection.

The plasma Flt3L increase observed in acute, uncomplicated falciparum or knowlesi malaria, are consistent with previous studies that found plasma Flt3L levels to be increased in clinical disease [19, 20]. In children, Flt3L levels are significantly higher in severe malaria patients compared to uncomplicated malaria patients [19], however, Flt3L concentrations reported in uncomplicated malaria in children are lower than those recorded in adults in this study and by others [20]. In adults with uncomplicated malaria, higher Flt3L levels are positively correlated with parasitaemia [20] yet, here there was no correlation with parasitaemia during clinical malaria. A parasite density threshold may trigger Flt3L release, via sensing of uric acid crystal accumulation by mast cells as demonstrated in Plasmodium chabaudi infection [19, 30]. In mice, release of Flt3L by mast cells was reported to drive the expansion of splenic CD8α⁺ DCs [19]. Only one study has assessed mast cell function in human malaria, with increased activation of mast cells in patients with severe malaria when compared to uncomplicated malaria patients [29]. In contrast to clinical malaria, no increase in Flt3L during experimental infection was observed. These data suggest a parasite threshold and/or symptomatic disease are associated with Flt3L elevation in malaria.

In the current study, no association between plasma Flt3L and CD141⁺ DC, CD1c⁺ DC or pDC peripheral cell numbers, in adults with clinical malaria, nor subpatent infection. Rather, despite increased Flt3L in clinical malaria, circulating CD141⁺ DCs and other DC subsets were significantly reduced. Further, Flt3L plasma levels and DC subset numbers were comparable between convalescent patients and healthy controls. However, the recovery of DC subsets was not correlated with Flt3L. These observations may be explained by the role of other haematopoietic cytokines including GM-CSF, M-CSF and IL-4 in DC development [30, 31]. In mice, the lack of Flt3L is compensated by increased production of M-CSF and IL-4, which results in continued expansion of DCs from progenitor cells [24]. Paradoxically, DC numbers significantly expand from progenitor cells when Flt3L receptor is deleted, suggesting multiple cytokines can induce DC development [24]. Future studies are required to assess M-CSF and other DC generating cytokines longitudinally in clinical malaria cohorts and the associations of these factors with DC subsets. The lack of an observed correlation between Flt3L and parasitaemia or DC subsets during clinical malaria could also be impacted by the limited longitudinal sampling within our cohorts and restricted sample numbers.

Conclusions

In summary, similar to classical CD1c⁺ DCs (6), and pDCs (7) CD141⁺ DCs are reduced during experimental P. falciparum infection. Similarly, this study shows that pDC, CD1c⁺ DC and CD141⁺ DCs subsets are significantly reduced during clinical falciparum and for the first time, also in knowlesi malaria. These data suggest that Flt3L released in adults with uncomplicated malaria may not be sufficient to expand or restore circulating DC subsets during acute infection. Rather, multiple signals, not just Flt3L, may be required to expand CD141⁺ DCs and other DC subsets [30, 31].